Sunday, November 22, 2026

Electric Miles

I've recently returned to Miles Davis electric period, which I never liked.

It always seemed poseurish. Given that Miles was 43 when he released "In a Silent Way", the first (and perhaps best) of his electric recordings, I couldn't help but view this as Miles' midlife crisis. Striking poses, being cool, and getting down with the funky stuff the kids are fond of. "I've still got it!"

Back in my musician days, I learned not to say this out loud, because it made serious musicians want to punch me in the face. They insisted this music was substantial, and that I was not sophisticated enough to dig it. You dig?

Upon reexamination, I'll concede this...halfway.

I know some of the players, and have heard things through the musician network. They were all naturally thrilled to be there, playing with the great Miles Davis, but in most cases it absolutely wasn't their personal thing. Few continued in that style after leaving the band. Miles may have wanted to be James Brown, but the rest couldn't have been less temperamentally suited to fuel his fantasy. Keith Jarrett, for example, hated electric keyboards, but had no other choice if he wanted the gig.

Yet he sounded great on that Fender Rhodes! Like he was born to play it! And this observation brings it all together.

This is substantial music because the musicians are uniformly great, so anything they played was worth listening to and studying. Jarrett killed on that stupid electric piano. And killing music is worth listening to, period.

In a sense, we're witnessing a torture chamber, with subtle players compelled to play shitty poseurish music in order to gig with Miles. But, regardless of that headwind, they're great, so they played great. They played shitty music great. And great is great.

In fact, that's the foundation of jazz, historically. Ever since Ella Fitzgerald recorded "A-Tisket, A-Tasket", making the squarest song in the world sound hip and swinging, jazz musicians have livened up flat material. The entire tin pan alley canon was square music transmogrified. "My Favorite Things", once famously warbled by Julie Andrews, was somehow reforged into an indelible jazz standard.

In fact, let's go back a few more decades. The very beginning of jazz consisted of fucking around with marches and stiff parlor songs, investing them with attitude and cockeyed vernacular their composers could never have foreseen.

Electric Miles is substantial music even though the vehicle sucks (and, Jesus, does it suck) because jazz has always been about transcending the vehicle. And Jarrett soulfully pounding those chunky electric keys alongside guys like Dave Liebman serving as groovy bar mitzvah band saxophonist, plus all the rest, redeem the bullshit, giving great performances because they were great performers.

Which leaves the leader as the odd man out. Miles certainly wasn't working around the shit vehicle he'd conjured. He bought in! All the way! This was his bar mitzvah! So the hairs on the back of my neck never stand up as he spits his signature staccato muted gestures from the bell of his superfunky purple trumpet. He's essentially playing it straight. Flat. Transcending nothing. The hippest musician in the world somehow managed to trap himself!

But he hired well, and let great players be great. So it's great, like great musicians working a wedding reception. They make it great because they're great, and great is great.

No comments:

Blog Archive