The next time you look in your rear view mirror and notice someone way behind you, giving the visceral impression that you're leading them, consider the possibility that you might have been lapped. Perhaps several times.
Perhaps trillions of times.
Maybe that person is not behind you, after all. Maybe you were never, in fact, leading, even though the mirror seemed to offer incontrovertible evidence that they're back there while you're up here.
Anyone who gets good at something—or clear-eyed about something—will inevitably experience patronization from below. You'd expect wise, experienced parties to pepper you with shrewd critique. Flaws found, bugs logged, etc. You'd be put through the mill, but all in a process of improvement! But, no. That rarely happens. Rather, shitty drivers of shitty cars sneer and pelt your vehicle with shitty soda cans as their beleaguered engines fart out black greasy smoke, framing themselves as jubilant winners because, hey, rear view mirrors never lie!
Critique is rarely enlightened. Patronization is most often—and very, very weirdly!—from below.
The customary response is to unsheath one's sword and do battle, huffily howling "Do you know who I am?" while pummeling your antagonist with the full weight of your résumé, chock full of accomplishment.
Nothing is achieved, but it's a challenge one can't comfortably refuse. I once wrote about how those who decline such battle forfeit their legitimacy:
"If you don't project superiority - if you're not a pompous, boastful, stuck-up "Do You Know Who I Am?!?" prick, leading with your accomplishments, playing the part, and prepared to pee at least as hard and as far as any alphas in your midst, it's surprisingly tough to be taken the least bit seriously by anyone."
Declining to fight for jive positioning in an absurd propositional hierarchy does not, alas, ease one into peaceful stability. First of all, that very renunciation adds a few more laps, further augmenting the woozy distortion of it all.
And even remaining unprovoked, patronization from below is still extraordinarily confusing. Disorienting. Destabilizing. Not because it makes you doubt your (fake) positioning, but because it makes you doubt your efforts. It's debilitating to the effort to do a good job. Ego entirely aside, it's simply bad feedback.
And bad feedback is the worst. It's insidiously corrupting. Negative reaction to good work can make a person crazy. Psychologists will attest that randomized feedback can be profoundly damaging for an organism.
Ideally, one would conjure a mature confidence, unflappably recognizing the value of one's effort despite the hails of faux-superior potshots, sidestepping provocation to haughty self-declaration and pointless battle. One would view this all through a clear lens, maintaining unperturbed self-assurance. One man, at least, might be an island, no?
No. Such squeaky-clean confidence is unsustainable in the real world. We are, after all, social creatures. So we wind up either unmoored by crisis of confidence, or else provoked into a defensive stance over a false notion of hierarchy that should have merely exasperated us.
No comments:
Post a Comment